Showing posts with label 14th Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 14th Amendment. Show all posts
Sunday, May 18, 2008
Equal Rights?
I was enjoying a cigar with my brother last night when conversation drifted to the recent ruling in California that legalized gay marriage. I realize I'm going to get some flack for what I'm about to say, but I don't give a damn.
I remarked that while I have no problem with homosexual civil unions, I don't agree with something like "gay marriage." It's always been my opinion that marriage is between a man and a woman, and should indeed be a sacred commitment between that one man and that one woman.
I explained that as far as civil unions, I don't see how, given the legal framework (i.e., the 14th Amendment), the United States government could deny tax and other legal benefits to individuals in committed relationships with another individual of the same sex. I just don't agree with the use of the term marriage.
My brother pointed out that from one standpoint, it's not about equal rights. For instance, a heterosexual man cannot marry another man. That's something that was illegal for every man - gay or straight.
Ah, you say. It's not about that. It's that people should be able to marry whomever they love, correct?
All right, then. Take this scenario: A man and a woman apply for a marriage license, saying they're very deeply in love, and can't wait.
The clerk has them fill out the paperwork, and it turns out both individuals sign with the same last name.
The clerk asks if it's a coincidence.
It's not, they say. They're brother and sister. They just happen to be very deeply in love.
Now you say that will never happen. That's outrageous to suggest it! But I think it could be said that there was definitely a time when "gay marriage" was unthinkable, as well.
This takes us back to the legal framework that I mentioned earlier: the Equal Protection Clause. It basically says no rights can arbitrarily (or on the basis of any discrimination) be denied to one individual, while granted to another. Given the nature of this amendment, isn't it the correct legal course now for the government to legalize and sanction any sort of union between anybody? We have to no choice now but to be fair and open the doors to incest, polygamy, and polyandry. I could go on, but I risk being misquoted and villified already.
My brother and I have concluded a simple solution for this: end any sort of government benefit for marriage or civil unions, even for heterosexual couples. Certainly, such benefits were in the past intended to promote the growth of families as the basic unit of society, but frankly, I don't think that should be government's job. In my perfect world, government would provide basic national defense and protect - not grant - the welfare of its citizens. The importance of the family is much more integral in religious institutions, who have their own verdicts on this issue. With that said, I don't think government should be exclusive to families, either. I don't think my suggestion would be.
Don't get me wrong. I don't care what people want to do in their private lives, as long as it causes no harm to another individual without that individual's consent. But I don't want my tax dollars going to support something to which I object. That's been said about the war in Iraq, and now I'm saying it about gay marriage.
Do what you want, folks. I swear I'm not trying to preach to anyone. An individual's choice is his or her own. Just don't ask me to pay for it, if I would never make the choice myself.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)