Showing posts with label CNN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CNN. Show all posts

Sunday, April 18, 2010

iSeeYou! Big Brother Issues iMacs



While the Harrington High School teen's story seems disturbing, it seems to be equally extreme to remove these types of tracking technologies off of computers in the event that they are stolen. In this particular instance, based on the one-sided comments of the plaintiffs, the school's actions crossed the line when, after reaching an agreement about the computer insurance fee and realizing that the computer was not in fact stolen, chose to repeatedly activate the photo-tracking technology and delete the pictures.

However, the family is also responsible for reading and understanding the terms of the agreement regarding the insurance fee and what programs will be activated. These tracking technologies, while out of place in this particular instance, are a valuable security measure for recovering a missing or stolen computer (as long as the thief is not smart enough to cover the microphone and camera) and it makes sense for the school to have such measures in place. CNN reports that "the school district installed the LANrev webcam security system for use if the laptop is reported lost, missing or stolen."

Unfortunately, this story does not make clear the response of the Lower Merion School District school district nor its current actions after the Robbins family filed their lawsuit. According to this article, "both state and federal officials are investigating the district for possible wiretap violations."

The New York Times reports that "using this surveillance capability, school officials found images that led them to believe that Blake Robbins, a 15-year-old student, was using illegal drugs. Mr. Robbins said the 'pills' he was seen consuming were Mike and Ike candies." However, if the purpose of the camera activation technology is to prevent theft or damage to the laptops, as the school states, then it is irrelevant whether or not the school thought that the student was consuming illegal drugs, as the computer was not damaged nor was it stolen. As the editorial in the New York Times pointedly argues, "If the district was really worried about losing the laptops, it could have used GPS devices to track their whereabouts or other less-intrusive methods. Whatever it did, the school had a responsibility to inform students that if they accepted the laptops, they would also accept monitoring."

Yes, the school district does bear the responsibility of informing the students about the technology with which the laptops are equipped, but in the digital age, it is also important for individuals to know and understand these technologies and their proper usage. The laptops did not belong to the students and if the students take them home under the terms of the agreement made with the school, it seems unreasonable to expect complete privacy using property belonging to a public school district. Despite all of these factors, based on the available information, the school district grossly overstepped its rights when realizing that, as the laptop was not missing, damaged, or stolen, and still chose to activate and reactivate the software.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Argentina's Got 'Em by the Balls


Before beginning this commentary, it is important to note that the “chemical castration” is a drug given to reduce sexual desire; this is not the equivalent of a castration in the literal sense. However, this still brings up a controversial issue when addressing what the purpose of a criminal justice system is – solely doling out punishments for crimes committed, or is there an additional component of rehabilitation? Furthermore, is there and should there be an element of choice (proposition, as opposed to imposition/coercion) for convicted rapists regarding a treatment which is ineffective once the regimen is stopped? The reporter in the video states that those who do not volunteer to undergo this type of treatment will not have the same access to appealing for sentence reductions; there are currently 11 convicted offenders who have opted for this treatment in return for reduced sentences.


In the video clip, Mendoza Governor Celso Jaque states that the chemical and psychological treatment enables those convicted to be able to be reintroduced to society. However, with the risks that Enrique da Rosa highlights, the treatment’s effectiveness is relative and fails to be comprehensive enough to address significant factors contributing to why a rapist commits a rape or sexual assault.


While this report addresses a province in Argentina, “the practice in Mendoza follows measures adopted in several European countries and eight U.S. states: California, Florida, Georgia, Montana, Oregon, Wisconsin, Louisiana and Iowa.” In any of these cases, if there is a lack of access to the same legal channels for those who opt out of the treatment as those who select the treatment have, then this sentencing option is more of a coercive measure and should not be described as an elective procedure. Additionally, the information presented by CNN in this segment totally overlooks the problematic situation of the effects on an innocent person who was convicted and then chooses this procedure in order to reduce his or her sentence. How reversible is the process?


All in all, the imposition of this treatment upon prisoners seems to go beyond both concepts of what the purpose of the criminal justice system is. If prisons are seen solely as places of punishment for crimes committed, then time spent in prison would be sufficient. If the criminal justice system is seen as integrating punishment and rehabilitation, then a treatment that is highly relative with an unknown degree of its effects on an individual’s health is not the best course of action. While a holistic approach to addressing root causes of crimes is appreciated, these courses of action must be sensitive to all individuals’ rights as well as be much more certain than this procedure.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Ahmadinejad on Larry King

This is the interview between Larry King and Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.



He may be the Iranian version of George Bush, however, he makes some valid points amid the rest. One example of this is the double standard of the US calling on the IAEA to do more investigations on Iran than in the history of the organization rather than allowing themselves to be monitored. While Ahmadinejad may not be the best at promoting positive relations between Iran and Israel to say the least, he makes a point that the US avoids which is the plight of the Palestinean people.

While there are some valid points made, Ahmadinejad doesn't disappoint American audiences. His comments regarding Iran's own human rights issues and homosexuality are still as concerning as ever.

So, what's the answer?

Diplomacy. Diplomacy. Diplomacy.

Thursday, June 26, 2008

Supreme Court Rulings, Pt. 1: The Death Penalty




The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 5-4 Wednesday that child rapists cannot be executed, concluding that capital punishment for crimes against individuals can be applied only to murderers.

Patrick Kennedy, 43, was on Louisiana's death row after being convicted of raping his 8-year-old stepdaughter.  The ruling stemmed from the case of Patrick Kennedy, who appealed the 2003 death sentence he received in Louisiana after being convicted of raping his 8-year-old stepdaughter.

Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion that execution in this case would violate the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, citing "evolving standards of decency" in the United States.  Such standards, the justice wrote, forbid capital punishment for any crime against an individual other than murder.

"We conclude that, in determining whether the death penalty is excessive, there is a distinction between intentional first-degree murder on the one hand and nonhomicide crimes against individual persons, even including child rape, on the other," wrote Kennedy, who is not related to the convicted rapist.
As this is a blog, here's the editorial part of the post. I personally disagree with the death penalty being used for any crime first and foremost because deciding when another person should die seems like a highly-flawed system that is backwards and opposed to the purpose of human life (this take on the right to life should not be confused with my documented pro-choice stance nor should the right to life regarding the death penalty be confused and conflated with the right to die, as in refusing treatment, etc.).

First, some insight by famous people who are far smarter than myself. There is a reason that the vast majority of the world evolved beyond Hammurabi's Code. In the words of Mohandas "Mahatma" Gandhi, "An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind."  While the purpose of human life is constantly pondered by everyone who attempt to answer this evasive question in numerous ways, including religion, the late Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. summed it up best in "Sirens of Titan" stating, "The purpose of human life, no matter who is controlling it, is to love whoever is around to be loved."  

From a different standpoint, the intentional killing of another person, unless in a situation where self defense of any other kind is impossible, is first degree murder, no matter who the killer(s) is/are.

One of the most heated issues surrounding the death penalty debate is the role that DNA testing plays in determining guilt or innocence of the accused.  With more and more technological developments, many wrongly convicted people have finally been acquitted due to the proof of innocence that DNA testing provides.  However, in many cases, there is no DNA evidence available to be tested for definitive proof of guilt or innocence.  In such situations, there can almost never be 100%  certainty of guilt that would demand such a strong sentence.  
 As Benjamin Franklin said, "That it is better 100 guilty persons should escape than that one innocent person should suffer, is a maxim that has been long and generally approved. They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."   Agreed.

Furthermore, states without the death penalty have consistently lower murder rates.  Therefore, not only is the death penalty ineffective at determining real guilt but states that choose capital punishment also end up suffering from the very criminal actions that they are trying to prevent.

Additionally, the United States prides itself on being a progressive country that is a model for the rest of the world.  So it makes perfect sense that the USA uses a form of punishment exempt from the 8th Amendment and continues an ancient practice of state-sponsored murder (wars could also fall under this category), riiight?  WRONG.  The USA is actually one of the few "developed" countries in the world to still have the death penalty legally allowed.  For the breakdown of countries, click here.  While our "oh-so-effective" criminal justice system helped us to become the country in the world with the largest percentage of our population imprisoned with a total of 2 million people (80% of which are minorities and 70% of the 2 million being imprisoned for petty crimes. Oh yeah!  Also, we build more prisons than schools), we also made the list of countries that execute the most people per year.  WE'RE NUMBER ONE!  WE'RE NUMBER ONE!

Amnesty International has some more to say:

Key facts:  
-137 countries have abolished the death penalty in law or practice.
-60 countries retain and use the death penalty, most often as a punishment for people convicted of murder.
-At least 1,252 people were known to be executed in 24 countries during 2007. The true figure was certainly higher.
-88 per cent of all known executions in 2007 took place in China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and the USA.
 
For the full CNN article, click here.
For the Amnesty International webpage on the Death Penalty, click here.

Saturday, March 15, 2008

"War is Peace"

Leave it to the Chinese government to restrict protests, then twist events, and intensify martial law, while simultaneously denying their crimes. This time, the Chinese government has turned a week of the most intense protesting seen in Tibet and the rest of the world in decades into yet another myth. As Jim Yardley of The New York Times reports,
BEIJING — Thousands of Buddhist monks and other Tibetans clashed with the riot police in a second Chinese city on Saturday, while the authorities said they had regained control of the Tibetan capital, Lhasa, a day after a rampaging mob ransacked shops and set fire to cars and storefronts in a deadly riot.

Residents in Lhasa, the Tibetan capital, walked through Barkhor, an ancient part of the city where protesters had set fire to a shop and several vehicles on Friday. Conflicting reports emerged about the violence in Lhasa on Friday. The Chinese authorities denied that they had fired on protesters there, but Tibetan leaders in India told news agencies on Saturday that they had confirmed that 30 Tibetans had died and that they had unconfirmed reports that put the number at more than 100.
Chinese authorities defended their response to the violence in Lhasa. “We fired no gunshots,” said Qiangba Puncog, chairman of the Tibet Autonomous Regional Government, according to state media.

But Tibetan advocacy groups and witnesses in Lhasa offered contradictory accounts. The Tibetan government in exile said at least 30 Tibetans died in the protests, according to Agence France-Presse. Witnesses told Radio Free Asia, the nonprofit news agency financed by the United States government, that numerous Tibetans were dead. A 13-year-old Tibetan boy, reached by telephone, said he watched the violence from his apartment and saw four or five Tibetans fall to the ground after military police officers fired upon them.
The protests also disprove yet another lie propagated by Chinese authorities.
The tumult also undercuts a theme regularly promoted by China’s propaganda officials — that Tibetans are a happy minority group, smoothly integrated into the country’s broader ethnic fabric.
It is sad that such a peaceful people simply desiring freedom and democracy are only noticed as endangered by a repressive government when they are provoked to lashing out in violence against an oppressor infinitely larger than themselves. As Wolf Blitzer reports,


Clearly, people across the world are calling for action to prevent the genocide China has engaged in since 1949 that has been largely ignored by the international community. The plight of the Tibetan people is one that is rooted in the minds of all people, regardless of their origin. As a promoter of democracy and a nation vowed to uphold the Geneva Conventions, the United States is in a key position of influence to encourage and persuade the Chinese government to stop its murderous campaigns and allow Tibet to uphold its culture and the democracy they desire through meaningful autonomy.

Or, better yet, independence.

For the rest of the story, click here.

For more by Jim Yardley, click here.


Friday, March 14, 2008

A Judge and a Lucky Bastard

CNN International reported today that India's top court is indefinitely suspending an arrest warrant against American actor and humanitarian Richard Gere for offending cultural sensibilities by kissing Indian Bollywood star Shilpa Shetty at an AIDS Awareness event in April 2007.



In the immortal wisdom of Jon Stewart, that would offend "cultural sensibilities" in the United States, too.

Next time, act less like an American and learn a little something about the people of a country you've been visiting for over 30 years. It's easy. Just ask for a transfer off Ethnocentric Express and take the B-Train to Relativism because the Lucky Bastard line isn't always in operation.